I had an interesting conversation with some bookish friends the other day about books we’re currently reading and we got onto the topic of how new books that we have recently read tended to have strong main characters, often ‘perfect’ or tough protagonists who can handle anything thrown at them. It was something that, admittedly, I hadn’t given much thought too beforehand, even as an author. Once I started thinking of this topic, it occurred to me that more often than not on social media lately, I had seen authors displaying their books with arrows and advertising labels such as “strong female lead”. It got me thinking about a few things, from a writing point of view, regarding protagonists in fiction, which inspired my blog post today.

Are strong characters relatable?

Clearly there is a need for strong main characters, or role-model types in fiction, since there is clearly a market for it. Personally, whilst I can see the benefit of a protagonist having positive traits, I don’t tend to gravitate to stories with strong main characters. If I’m honest, strong heroes or heroines in fiction don’t appeal to me, simply because I don’t think they’re realistic of the majority of people in real life, and therefore I don’t find such characters inspirational. As a reader, a character who is inherently perfect and deals with all obstacles in their path with ease is boring. As a writer, where is the room for character growth and development if a protagonist is already strong? No character arc for me means no story.

Flawed characters in an imperfect world

If I’m reading a book, I enjoy reading about flawed people who face considerable challenges, which force them on a journey of introspection. I like it when they succumb to their own darkness for a time, then change and grow as a result; or become consumed as a result of their own flaws. That’s much more interesting to me than any false and unrealistic ‘hero’. Let’s face facts: in real life everyone is flawed. How many of those people have overcome trauma? Lifted themselves out of adversity? Battled onwards despite devastating bad luck? I’d rather read about those people than some pretentious, perfect hero.

Strong characters in YA books versus adult fiction

Children need role models. They need to see people like themselves. They need to see how to navigate obstacles. But do they need a perfect, strong character to do this? I really don’t think so. To be flawed is realistic. Just as I feel imperfect people make great characters for adult fiction, I believe the same is true of YA books. When I was a teen, I related to the underdogs in stories; I rooted for them, not the little-miss-perfect who did everything right, was tough as all hell and a rock for others at the same time. I’ve never known any such people in real life, so such stories don’t provide me with any inspiration.

What do you think? Would you rather have a main character with flaws who could easily be from real life, or a ‘strong’ character who lives only in the realm of fantasy?

About Leilanie Stewart

Leilanie Stewart is an author and poet from Belfast, Northern Ireland. She has written four novels, including award-winning ghost horror, The Blue Man, as well as three poetry collections. Her writing confronts the nature of self; her novels feature main characters on a dark psychological journey who have a crisis of identity and create a new sense of being. She began writing for publication while working as an English teacher in Japan, a career pathway that has influenced themes in her writing. Her former career as an Archaeologist has also inspired her writing and she has incorporated elements of archaeology and mythology into both her fiction and poetry. In addition to promoting her own work, Leilanie runs Bindweed Magazine, a creative writing literary journal with her writer husband, Joseph Robert. Aside from publishing pursuits, Leilanie enjoys spending time with her husband and their lively literary lad, a voracious reader of sea monster books. CONNECT WITH ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA: https://mailchi.mp/75c5a1ad6956/leilanie-stewart-author-info

2 responses »

  1. I love me a flawed character. All of the characters I’ve written about are flawed, too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s